|
PRELIMINARY
NUTRITIONAL EVALUATION OF FIVE SPECIES OF EGUSI SEEDS IN CAMEROON
Fokou
E 1, Achu MB*2 and FM Tchounguep3
ABSTRACT
This study deals with the analyses of the quantity of moisture,
crude proteins, total lipids, carbohydrates, ash, crude fibre and
calcium. These analyses were carried out in five different species
of egusi seeds, which belong to the Cucurbitaceae family.
These seeds are: Cucumeropsis mannii (egusi melon), Cucurbita
maxima (pumpkin or squash gourd), Cucurbita moschata (musk
melon), Lagenaria siceraria (bottle gourd or calabash)
and Cucumis sativus (“Ibo” egusi).
The moisture content was determined by drying in an oven to constant
weight, crude protein content by Kjedahl method. Total lipids by
Soxhlet, ash content by incinerating in a furnace and carbohydrates
by the Bertrand’s method. The crude fibre content was the
residue obtained after sequential hot digestion of the defatted
sample with dilute acid and alkaline solutions. The calcium content
was determined by the complexiometric method.
From this study, it was noticed that the moisture levels (4.33 -
7.25% f.w) were similar to those of other oilseeds such as soybean
and the fluted pumpkin seed. These egusi samples contained good
levels of crude proteins (24.3 - 41.6% d.w), total lipids (42.9
- 57.3% d.w) and calcium (129.7 - 269.7 mg/100 g d.w). Their levels
of crude proteins were similar to those of soybean and the fluted
pumpkin but higher than that of groundnut (23% d.w), while the total
lipid contents were similar to those of groundnut and the fluted
pumpkin seed but higher than that of soybean (19.1% d.w). The carbohydrate
contents of these seeds (4.56 – 10.2% d.w) are lower than
those of groundnut (18.6% d.w) and the fluted pumpkin seed (14.5%
d.w). The crude fibre levels (0.9 – 1.63% d.w) were lower
than those of soybean (5.71% d.w) and groundnuts (5.15% d.w). The
ash contents of these seeds (2.82 - 5.0% d.w) were similar to those
of groundnuts (2.79% d.w), soybean (5.06% d.w) and the fluted pumpkin
seed (3.4% d.w). Calcium levels compared well with that of soybean,
higher than that of groundnut (49 mg/100 g d.w) and even higher
than that of the fluted pumpkin seed (1.1 mg/100 g d.w).
These egusi seeds can therefore be considered as an important source
of plant proteins, lipids and calcium, which could be used in the
fight against malnutrition.
Key words: nutritional potential, Cucurbitaceae,
egusi seeds.
FRENCH
ETUDE NUTRITIONNELLE PRELIMINAIRE DE 5 ESPECES DE COURGES DE LA
FAMILLE DE CUCURBITACEES DU CAMEROUN
Resumé
Cette étude analyse les potentiels nutritionnels de cinq
espèces de courges de la famille de Cucurbitacées
à savoir : Cucumeropsis mannii, Cucurbita maxima, Cucurbita
moschata, Lagenaria siceraria et Cucumis sativus .Sept principes
nutritifs ont été évalués : L’eau,
les protides totaux, les lipides totaux, les glucides, les cendres,
les fibres brutes et le calcium.
Les résultats obtenus montrent que les teneurs en eau et
en cendres sont généralement semblables à celles
des autres graines oléagineux tandis que les teneurs en glucides
et en fibres brutes sont plus faibles. Les courges contiennent essentiellement
les protides totaux (24.3 - 41.6%), les lipides totaux (42.9 - 57.3%
m.s.) et le calcium (129.7 - 269.7 mg/100 m.s). Leurs teneurs en
protéines sont presque les mêmes que celles de Glycine
max (soja) et de Telfaria occidentalis mais supérieure à
celle d’Arachis hypogyaea (arachide) (23% m.s.) Les teneurs
en lipides sont semblables à celle de Telfaria occidentalis
mais plus élevées que celle de soja (19% m.s). Les
teneurs en calcium sont presque les mêmes que celle de soja,
mais supérieur à celle d’arachide (49 mg/100
gm.s) et plus élevées que celle de Telfaria occidentalis
(1.1 mg/100 gm.s.).
Au vu de tous ces résultats, nous sommes amenés à
dire que ces espèces de courges constituent une source importante
de protéines végétales, de lipides et de calcium
qui sont indispensables pour la lutte contre la malnutrition.
Mots clés : potentiel nutritionnel, Cucurbitacées,
graines de courges
INTRODUCTION
Good health is achieved by eating the right kinds and amounts of
food. Well balanced human foods should contain adequate amounts
of nutrients, the shortage of which leads to malnutrition, which
is common in West Africa [1].
Malnutrition is a major health problem in Cameroon, despite government’s
efforts to promote food production. Protein-energy malnutrition
in infants and children is one of the most common nutritional problems
in Cameroon today [2].
Faced with this problem, the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)
of the United Nations and the World Health Organization (WHO) have
been mobilizing their resources to seek ways of improving the living
conditions of the poor.
Studies are being carried out on nutrition to find out, for instance,
which local dishes, soup ingredients and melon seeds are more nutritious
and good for human consumption. Examples of these studies include:
| (a) |
A nutritive study of some Cameroon dishes (Naching, Nang Tare and Mbedi) from the Far North, North West and East Provinces of Cameroon, respectively [3]; and |
| (b) |
An analysis of oil content and fatty acid composition of 36 species of seeds [4]. |
Studies on melon seeds have been limited to the quality of proteins
in four cultivated Cucurbit species [5] and a nutritional
assessment of defatted oil meals of melon (Colocynthis citrullus)
and fluted pumpkin (Telfaria occidentalis Hook) by Chick
Assay [6].
The underlying objective of all these studies has been to seek ways
of supplementing the nutrient content of staple carbohydrate foods.
The Cameroon population, for instance, can increase nutrient consumption
either by the use of oil seeds and legumes or by increasing the
nutrient consumption of expensive nutrient-containing foods of animal
origin such as meat, milk and fish. Oil seeds remain the best option
since the rural population can cultivate them. In Cameroon, there
is a large variety of legumes and oil seeds such as egusi which
are part of the traditional food system. However, the nutritional
and economic values have not been completely determined, far less
exploited, which are of good nutritional value similar to soyabean.
Edible leguminous oil seeds are excellent sources of dietary protein.
Preliminary results indicate that melon and fluted pumpkin seeds
are good sources of dietary oil and their defatted meals are exceptionally
higher in protein than in soyabean, peanut or sunflower seed meals
[6].
Vegetables such as cassava leaves, bitter leaves, huckleberry leaves,
melon leaves and okra cooked with egusi are popular and a delicacy
for many tribal groups in Cameroon. For bitter leaf soups, blends
of groundnut, soybean and egusi are better appreciated for their
odour, taste and mouth feel than soybean individually [7].
Egusi seed kernels are major soup ingredients in Cameroon. They
are used as a thickener and flavour component of soups. Egusi seeds
are less expensive and widely distributed. They can contribute substantially
towards obtaining a balanced diet and hence there is need to determine
their nutritional potential.
This study, therefore, aimed at determining the composition of egusi
seeds in as far as: moisture, crude proteins, total lipids, available
carbohydrates, ash, crude fibre and calcium. The five different
species of egusi seeds used in preparing soups were:
Cucumeropsis mannii (egusi melon),
Cucurbita maxima (pumpkin or squash gourd),
Cucurbita moschata (pepo) (musk melon),
Lagenaria siceraria (bottle gourd or calabash), and
Cucumis sativus (“Ibo”egusi).
These five species of egusi seeds belong to the family Cucurbitaceae
and are edible. They are annual, herbaceous, monoecious plants
with climbing stems. The fruits are indehiscent smooth berries,
which enclose many seeds [8]. For consumption, they can be ground
and used as ingredients to thicken soups or prepared into a paste
commonly called egusi pudding. The Mankon people of the
North West Province of Cameroon as a delicacy use this pudding,
called the “traditional cake” by most tribes in Cameroon,
during special occasions.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Collection and Treatment of samples
The egusi seeds were bought in Yaounde (Melen market). These seeds
were bought already dried under local conditions by the sellers
and transported in polyethylene bags to the laboratory. While in
the laboratory, they were cleaned with filter paper and dried to
constant weight in an oven at 100 to 105 oC for 48 to 72 hours.
They were ground using an electric grinder (BLENDER MILL/GRATER3),
put in airtight bottles and stored in a dessicator. Chemical analysis and moisture determination
The moisture content was determined by drying in an oven at 100
to 105 oC for 48 hours [9]. The crude protein content was estimated
by the Kjeldahl method [9], which consists of digestion, distillation
and titration. The nitrogen content (%) was converted to protein
by multiplying by 6.25. Total lipids were determined using the Soxhlet
method with petroleum ether (60 oC) as the solvent. The extraction
was run for 6 hours and the solvent was removed using a rotatory
evaporator. Ash was determined by incinerating in a Murfle Furnace
at 550 oC for 48 hours [10]. The carbohydrate content was estimated
through the extraction of water-soluble sugars using the method
of fractioning of carbohydrates. This was followed by the determination
of the content of soluble reducing sugars and total water-soluble
sugars by the modified Bertrand’s method [11] using Fehling’s
solution and titration with 0.1N KMnO4. The crude fibre content
was the residue obtained after sequential hot digestion of the defatted
sample with dilute acid and alkaline solutions [9]. The calcium
content was determined by a complexiometric method, which consists
of extraction of the biological material in water followed by titration
with 0.002M NiSO4 [9]. Statistical Analysis
The statistical analysis of data was by Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
using 5% level of significance with the package being Genstat 4.2. This enabled us to see the significant differences between the nutrients
of the various species of egusi seeds studied.
The experimental design was a simple completely randomised block
design with 5 varieties and 3 replications. The Duncan multiple
range statistical test was used to compare between means.
RESULTS
The results of analysis are shown in Table 1. The moisture content
is given in grams per 100 grams fresh weight (g/100 g f.w.) while
other contents - crude proteins, total lipids, reducing sugars,
total water-soluble sugars, ash and crude fibre - are given in grams
per 100 grams dry weight (g/100 g d.w.). The calcium content is
given in milligrams per 100 grams dry weight (mg/100 g dry weight)
.The values are given in the form: mean ± standard deviation. The
standard error of means (S.E.M) is also given.
DISCUSSION
From Table 1, the moisture contents of the egusi seeds analysed
ranged from 4.33% f.w. (Cucumis sativus) to 7.26% f.w (Cucurbita
moschata) with significant differences (P < 0.05) between
all the samples. The moisture content of Cucumis sativus was
similar to that of Pistacia vera reported elsewhere [12]. The moisture
contents of our samples were also similar to those of other oilseeds,
which are also used as soup thickeners in Cameroon such as the fluted
pumpkin, Telfaria occidentalis (5.0% f.w.) [13] and the
soybean, “M-79” (6.4% f.w.) [14]. The crude protein contents of our samples range from 24.3% d.w.
(C. sativus) to 41.6% d.w. (Cucumeropsis mannii),
which is significantly higher than the crude protein contents of
the other species (P < 0.05). This value of 24.3% d.w. for Cucumis
sativus was closer to the value of 25.8% d.w. obtained for
egusi (melon) seeds [15], 22.5% d.w. for the egusi, Pistacia
vera, [12], and 26% and 23% for melon seeds and pumpkin seeds,
respectively [16]. Some of these values were lower than those reported
for other oilseeds such as soybeans, Glycine max (40% d.w.)
[12], the fluted pumpkin seed, T. occidentalis (30.1% d.w.)
[13] and higher than that obtained for groundnuts, Arachis hypogaea
(23% d.w.) [16].
The total lipid levels fall between 42.9% d.w. (C. mannii)
and 57.3% d.w. (C. sativus), which is significantly higher
than the total lipid contents of the other species (P < 0.05).
The lipid contents of C. moschata and Lagenaria siceraria
are 48.6 and 47.2% d.w., with no significant difference between
the lipid levels of these two species. These were similar to the
value of 49.7% d.w. obtained for egusi (melon) seeds by [15]. The
fat content of Cucurbita maxima was also shown to be 45.6%
d.w. [13]. The total lipid content of Cucumeropsis mannii
is 42.9% d.w., which was closer to that of Pistacia vera (45.7%
d.w.) [15]. The lipid contents of our samples also compared well
with those of groundnuts (47.5% d.w.) [17] and the fluted pumpkin
seed (47% d.w.) [13], but higher than for soyabeans (19.1% d.w.)
[17].
On the whole, the egusi samples studied have high lipid contents,
thus classifying melon seeds as excellent sources of dietary oil
[6]. The oil can be used for cooking and in the fabrication of pomades
and margarine. Also, seed kernels of the Cucurbit musk-melon (C.
maxima) appear promising as substitutes for the highly priced
cashew, almond and pistachio nuts in milk-based beverages and confections
[18].
The levels of soluble reducing sugars in these egusi seeds are between
0.49% d.w. (C. mannii) and 2.40% d.w. (Lagenaria siceraria) with significant differences between these values (P < 0.05). The total water-soluble sugars range from 2.87% d.w. (C. mannii)
to 4.51% d.w. (L. siceraria), except C. sativus with
a total water-soluble sugar content of 10.2% d.w., which is significantly
higher than the total water-soluble sugar content of the other species
of egusi seeds (P < 0.05).
The carbohydrate contents of our samples determined by the Bertrand’s
method were similar to those obtained by other researchers by the
difference method. Such was the case of pumpkin seeds with a carbohydrate
content of 10% d.w [19], which was quite close to that of Cucumis
sativus. This means that Cucumis sativus can be considered
an important source of energy and thus be used to prepare soups
especially for people engaged in heavy activity. The values for
egusi seeds were lower than those of other oil seeds such as groundnuts
(18.6% d.w) and the fluted pumpkin (14.5% d.w.), obtained by the
difference method [13, 17].
The presence of carbohydrates (especially reducing sugars) and
proteins in our samples can result in non-enzymatic browning reactions
leading to the formation of brown polymers and unfavourable modifications
rendering the foodstuff inedible, thus decreasing its nutritional
value. These modifications can take place if these samples are exposed
in the atmosphere for long periods of time (several months). Non-enzymatic
browning is the limiting factor in the preservation of these dehydrated
samples [20].
The crude fibre contents of these seeds are from 0.90% d.w. (Cucumis
sativus) to 1.63% d.w. (Lagenaria siceraria), which
is significantly higher than the crude fibre contents of the other
species of egusi seeds (P < 0.05). The crude fibre contents were
slightly lower than that of pumpkin seeds (2% d.w.) [19] and also
lower than the cellulose content of 2.99% for the egusi, Pistacia
vera [12]. They were, however, much lower than the values obtained
for oil seeds such as soybeans (5.71% d.w.) and groundnuts (5.15%
d.w.) [17]. On the whole, the egusi seeds studied have low fibre
levels, an indication that they cannot be considered good sources
of fibre.
However, the fibre present in these samples, though of low levels,
could contribute to the important role of fibre in the diet, that
of helping to stimulate peristalsis, thus aiding the movement of
food through the digestive system, thereby preventing constipation,
according to Uddoh [15].
The ash contents range from 2.82% d.w. (Cucumeropsis mannii)
to 5.0% d.w. (Cucurbita moschata). There are significant
differences (P < 0.05) between the ash contents of all the samples.
The ash content of Pistacia vera was 3.14% [12] showing
no marked difference. Our values also compared well with those of
groundnuts (2.79% d.w.), soyabean (5.06% d.w.) [17] and the fluted
pumpkin seed (3.40% d.w.) [13]. The results show that our samples
have significant amounts of ash, which are important sources of
minerals. These minerals aid in the building of bones and teeth.
Finally, the calcium contents of our samples vary from 129.7 mg/100
g d.w. (Cucurbita maxima) to 269.7 mg/100 g d.w. (C.
mannii), which is significantly higher than the calcium levels
of the other species of egusi seeds. These values were much higher
than that of 40 mg/100 g d.w. for pumpkin seeds [19] and 53 mg/100
g d.w. for egusi and melon seeds respectively [15, 16]. The value
for pumpkin seeds was also shown to be 57 mg/100 g d.w. [16].
These values compared well with that of oil seeds such as soyabean
(185 mg/100 g d.w.) but higher than that of groundnuts, 49 mg/100
g d.w. [16]. They are very much higher than that of the fluted pumpkin
seed, which had only a trace of calcium (1.1 mg/100 g d.w.) [13].
However, the samples investigated in this study can be considered
as sources of calcium, especially Cucumeropsis mannii with
high quantities of calcium and crude proteins. This species is therefore
good in the preparation of children’s soups. The proteins
will help in the growth and maintenance of their tissues while calcium
will help in the structure of their bones and teeth, thus helping
to prevent rickets. Cucumis sativus can be considered as an important source
of energy, Cucurbita moschata as a source of minerals and
Lagenaria siceraria as a source of cellulose for digestion.
These species can therefore be selected for desirable characteristics
and made available to farmers for wider cultivation .
CONCLUSIONS
The analysis of these egusi seeds has led us to conclude that the
moisture and protein levels of these seeds are similar to those
of soybeans and the fluted pumpkin seed. They have higher protein
levels than found in groundnut. Their lipid and ash contents are
similar to those of groundnut and the fluted pumpkin, while their
carbohydrate and fibre levels are generally lower than those of
these seeds. Their calcium levels are similar to that of soybeans
but higher than that of groundnuts and the fluted pumpkin seed.
On the whole, we can say from these results that Cucumeropsis
mannii can be considered a source of protein and calcium, Cucumis
sativus as a source of lipids and carbohydrates and Cucurbita
moschata as a source of minerals. This study has enabled us
to confirm the role of egusi seeds of the Cucurbitaceae family
as a source of plant proteins, lipids, minerals and calcium in nutrition.
Further research could be conducted to:
•-Study the detailed composition of the lipids,
•-Study the nutritional quality of these Cucurbit seed
proteins,
•-Compare the acceptability of different traditional Cameroon
sauces made with addition of egusi oil seeds to improve nutritional
value,
•-Study the exploitation of the oil, and
•-Study the effect of some anti nutritional factors on the
quality of the proteins.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are very grateful to the team of researchers of the Nutrition
Centre of IMPM, Yaounde especially to the Chief of Centre and Dr
Fotso Martin and the Laboratory technicians of this Centre for helping
us to do the analysis of the lipids of our samples in their laboratory. Our sincere thanks also go to Mr Kengni Edouard for helping in the
statistical analysis of our data.
We are also very grateful to Prof. Tchiégang Clergé for his useful suggestions towards the realization of this work.
Table 1
Nutrient Composition of Egusi Seeds |
Samples/Parameters |
Cucumeropsis mannii |
Cucurbita maxima |
Cucurbita moschata |
Lagenaria siceraria |
Cucumis sativus |
Standard error of means |
Moisture g/100gf.w |
5.63 ± 0.18b |
4.91 ± 0.02c |
7.26 ± 0.07a |
4.72 ± 0.03d |
4.33 ± 0.01c |
0.049 |
Crude Proteins g/100gd.w |
41.58 ± 0.18a |
29.97 ± 1.17c |
29.83 ± 1.61c |
34.89 ± 0.24 |
24.29 ± 0.47d |
0.98 |
Total Lipids g/100gd.w |
42.85 ± 0.78d |
52.02 ± 1.67b |
48.56 ± 0.65c |
47.22 ± 2.38c |
57.34 ± 2.12a |
1.44 |
Reducing Sugars g/100d.w |
0.49 ± 0.05c |
0.72 ± 0.23c |
0.66 ± 0.23c |
2.40 ± 0.32a |
2.02 ± 0.09b |
0.195 |
Total Water Soluble Sugars g/100d.w |
2.87 ± 0.53d |
3.38 ± 0.42c |
3.10 ± 0.24d |
4.51 ± 0.65b |
10.22 ± 0.14a |
0.32 |
Ash g/100gd.w |
2.82 ± 0.03e |
4.30 ± 0.13c |
5.00 ± 0.07a |
4.58 ± 0.12b |
4.03 ± 0.03d |
0.042 |
Crude Fibre g/100gd.w |
0.95 ± 0.05c |
1.09 ± 0.12b |
1.10 ± 0.07b |
1.63 ± 0.18a |
0.90 ± 0.16c |
0.101 |
Calcium mg/100gd.w |
269.67 ± 16.16a |
129.70 ± 16.16d |
157.69 ± 16.17c |
241.68 ± 32.33b |
157.69 ± 16.17d |
21.07 |
*Means with different letter superscript within each row are significantly different (p<0.05) |
REFERENCES
1.Briend A Prévention et Traitement de la Mlnutrition (guide
pratique. Edition de l’ORSTOM (Institut Français de
Recherche Scientifique pour le Développement en Coopération.
1985: 7-8. 2. Ngosom J and A Abondo Les Ressources Alimentaires du Cameroun.
Répartitions écologiques, classification et valeurs
nutritives, Cameroun – MESIRES - Institut de Recherche Médicinale
et d’études de plantes médicinales, Yaoundé.
1989: 5
3. Ajuh P Nutritive Study of Some Cameroon Dishes. Dissertation
presented as a partial requirement for the obtention of a “Maîtrise”
in Biochemistry. Biochemistry Service, Department of BPV, Faculty
of Science, University of Yaounde. 1985: 103
4. Osagie AU, Okoye WL, Oluwayoge BO and OA Dawodu Analysis of
Local Seed Lipids. Workshop on Nutrient Composition of Nigerian
Foods. Conference Centre, University of Ibadan. 1986: 3
5. Sharmer PB, Lal B, Madaan TR and SR Chatteyee Studies on the
Nutritional Quality of Some Cucurbit Kernel Proteins. J. Sci. Food
Agric, 1986; 4: 418-420.
6. Nwokolo E and JS Sim Nutritional Assessment of Defatted Oil
Meals of Melon (Colocynthis citrullus L) and Fluted Pumpkin (Telfaria
occidentalis Hook) by Chick Assay. J. Sci. Food Agri.1987; 3: 237-246.
7. Gwanfogbe RN, Chambers NE, Martin G, Fotso M and MF Smith Comparison
of the Acceptability of Traditional Cameroon Sauces made with Addition
of Oilseeds to Improve Nutritional value. Eco. Food Nutri. 1991;
25: 323-332.
8. Stevels JMC Légumes Traditionnels du Cameroun. Une Etude
Agro-botanique. Wageningen, Pays Bas. 1990 : 20-21,62-68,80, 132-153.
9. AOAC. Official Methods of Analysis. 13th Edn. William Horwit
(Ed.) Washington DC. 1980.
10. Bergeret B La Chimie Alimentaire dans un Laboratoire d’Outre
Mer. Organisation du Laboratoire; Etude Critique des Techniques
d’Analyses Employées au Laboratoire de la section Nutrition
de IRCAM, ORSTOM. 1955 : 1-56.
11. Bertrand G Dosage de Sucres Réducteurs In: Guide pour
les Manipulations de Chimie Biologie, Dunod et Pinat(Eds), Paris.
1913 : 20.
12. Valnet J Se Soigner par les Légumes, les Fruits et les
Céréales. 1985 ; 373: 415.
13. Asiegbu JE Some Biochemical Evaluation of Fluted Pumpkin Seed.
J. Sci. Food Agric. 1987; 2: 151-155
14. Olaofe O and EC Ndupuh Chemical Composition of Foods. Workshop
on Nutrient Composition of Nigerian Foods. Conference Centre, University
of Ibadan. 1986: 4
15. Uddoh CKO Nutrition. Macmillan Tropical Nursing and Health
Sciences Series. Macmillan International College editions, London
and Basingstoke. 1980: 24, 73, 89, 174
16. CTA, ECSA. Food Composition Table for Energy and 8 important
Nutrients for Foods Commonly eaten in East Africa. ACP-EEC. Lomé
Convention. 1987: 1
17. Oyenuga VA Nigeria’s Foods and Feeding-stuffs. Ibadan
University Press. 1968: 12-13, 66
18. Samant SK and DV Rege Some Enzymes and Enzyme Inhibitors from
Cucurbit Seeds. J. Sci. Food Agric.1989; 47: 283.
19. Platt BS Tables of Representative Values of Foods Commonly
used in Tropical Countries. London. 1962 : 10-12
20. Cheftel JC and H Cheftel Introduction à la Biochimie
et à la Technologie Alimentaire 1976 : 25-26.
|