|
NUCLEAR
AND ISOTOPIC TECHNIQUES APPLIED TO NUTRITIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL
PROJECTS SUPPORTED BY THE INTERNATIONAL ATOMIC ENERGY AGENCY (IAEA)
IN AFRICA
Mirinda-da-Cruz
B*1, Mokhtar N2, Iyengar GV3 and
B Smodis4
ABSTRACT
Nuclear
and isotopes methods have been used in industrialized countries
to enhance the sensitivity of nutrition and environmental monitoring
techniques. The isotope techniques used in nutrition research are:
(i) deuterium dilution to measure total body water (TBW) and body
composition for evaluating nutritional status, to assess nutrient
needs in dietary interventions and to perform impact analysis;(ii)
deuterium elimination to measure breast milk intake to evaluate
growth impact of weaning food interventions;(iii) double labelled
water to measure energy expenditure for assessing the amount of
dietary energy required and to identify whether an intervention
changed the energy requirements;(iv) vitamin A studies using deuterium
retinol or 13C-carotenoids for measuring total body vitamin A reserves;(v)
13C-amino acids and 15N labelling to measure the amount and rate
of protein turnover in the body to find out the most efficient conversion
of food to growth or maintenance of body protein stores; and (vi)
the use of isotopic labels iron, zinc, calcium, magnesium, copper
and selenium for nutrition monitoring. In conclusion, stable isotopes
are invaluable since there is virtually no health risk involved
when used correctly.
African countries are still struggling with many forms of malnutrition.
The lack of efficacy and effectiveness of nutrition interventions
is one of the factors that hamper the progress in eliminating malnutrition
in Africa.
It is recognized that both supplementation and food fortification
are effective means to correct nutritional deficiency of micronutrients
particularly Fe depending upon the field conditions faced. Although
significant progress seems to have been made to identify useful
fortificants, the final outcome is dependent upon the type of supplement
or fortificant used and the interactions between the nutrients involved
as well as cost-effectiveness including the potential to reach large
number of people. Nuclear and related isotopic techniques have been
demonstrated as a unique tool to measure micronutrient bioavailability.
Applications of isotope techniques in nutritional sciences are progressing
rapidly. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has a mandate
to promote the safe, secure and peaceful development of nuclear
technologies. The use of isotopes or nuclear related techniques
to evaluate human nutritional status and the nutritional quality
of the foods is at the core of IAEA’s program in the human
health area.
The objective of this review is to highlight the role of nuclear
and isotopic techniques supported by IAEA to address several nutrition
& environmental related projects in Africa.
French
Resumé
Les méthodes isotopiques et nucléaires ont été
employées dans les pays industrialisés pour augmenter
la sensibilité des techniques de mesure en nutrition et de
contrôle de l'environnement.
Il existe plusieurs techniques isotopiques utilisées dans
la recherche en nutrition comme: (i) la technique de dilution de
deutérium pour mesurer l'eau totale de corps et la composition
corporelle pour évaluer le statut nutritionnel etles besoins
en éléments nutritifs dans des interventions diététiques
aussi, pour faire l'analyse d'impact des stratégies nutritionnelles.
(ii) la technique d’élimination de deutérium
pour mesurer la quantité de lait maternel lors d’évaluation
d'impact de startegienutritionnelle sur la croissance du bébé;(iii)
la technique d’eau doublement marquée pour mesurer
la dépense énergétique afin d’évaluer
la quantité d'énergie nécessaire dans différentes
conditions et sur différentes populations;(iv) la technique
de mesure de la teneur corporelle en vitamine A en utilisant le
rétinol marque au deuterium ou le 13C-retinyl palmitate;(v)
Les acides aminés marqués au 13C et au 15N pour mesurer
la quantité de protéine dans le corps ; et (vi) l'utilisation
des isotopes stables de fer, zinc, calcium, magnésium, cuivre
et sélénium pour les études de biodisponibilité
et la surveillance nutritionnel.
Les isotopes stables sont de valeur inestimable puisqu'il n'y a
pratiquement aucun risque sanitaire impliqué s’ils
sont utilisés correctement.
Les pays africains luttent toujours contre plusieurs de formes de
malnutrition. Le manque d'efficacité et d’impact des
interventions en nutrition est l'un des facteurs qui entravent le
progrès dans l’élimination de la malnutrition
en Afrique.
Il est reconnu maintenant que la supplémentation et la fortification
alimentaire sont des moyens efficaces pour corriger l'insuffisance
en micronutriments en particulier en fer. Bien que beaucoup de progrès
semble avoir été accompli dans ce domaine, les résultats
dépendent du type de suppléments ou de fortifiants
utilisés et de la biodisponibilité des nutriments
impliqués. Les techniques isotopiques nucléaires ont
été désignées comme outil de choix pour
les études de disponibilité des micronutrients.
L'agence internationale de l'énergie atomique (l'AIEA) favorise
l’utilisation de la technologies nucléaires a des fins
de paix et de développement. L'utilisation des isotopiques
et nucléaires pour combattre la malnutrition est incluse
dans le programme de la santé humaine de l'IAEA.
L'objectif de cette revue est de décrire l’utilisation
des techniques nucléaires et isotopiques dans les études
nutritionnelles et de souligner les activités de l’AIEA
dans ce domaine en Afrique.
INTRODUCTION
Global nutrition problems (hunger, malnutrition, intrauterine growth
retardation, mineral deficiencies, obesity, cancer and osteoporosis
among others) are responsible for millions of deaths in developing
and developed countries. According to the United Nations sub-Committee
on Nutrition [1], the international community has the following
global challenges at the beginning of this millennium: 170 million
children <5 years are malnourished, 1.5 billion people are affected
by iron deficiency anaemia, 740 million people suffer from goitre,
230 million children are afflicted with subclinical vitamin A deficiency.
The worst conditions continue to be, largely, in Africa. One out
of every three people in sub-Sahara Africa is undernourished.
The
major nutrition problems facing Africa include protein energy malnutrition
and deficiencies of key micronutrients such as iron, iodine, and
vitamin A; diet-related non-communicable diseases, and HIV/AIDS.
In addition, three hundred million Africans, nearly half the region's
population, still live in extreme poverty. The spread of HIV/AIDS
threatens to wipe out important gains in life expectancy. The prevalence
of underweight preschool children in both Western and Eastern Africa
was about 36% in 2000, countries from this region are experiencing
a rise in underweight (30% in 1990) [1]. Estimates show that over
85 million people living in Africa are iodine deficient, 80% of
women, infants and young children suffer from anemia and vitamin
A is a public health problem in 64 African countries [2]. The 2002
World Health Report [3] confirms that at least 30% of all “disease
burden” measured in disability-adjusted life years (DALYs)
occurring in sub-Saharan Africa, is due to underweight, HIV/AIDS,
micronutrient deficiencies and water sanitation.
Preventing malnutrition in many of the African countries can save
thirty percent of infant and child deaths and twenty percent of
maternal mortality. Moreover, seventy percent of all illnesses related
to common infections can be prevented through improved nutrition
alone. Indeed, investments in nutritional programs have been shown
to be an effective way to improve child survival, poverty alleviation
and sustainable development. In Africa, progress has been made in
reducing the absolute number of hungry people. However, meeting
the UN Millennium Development Goals by 2015 of reducing hunger by
half raises difficult challenges in many African countries [4].
Nutrition
problems are inevitably linked with elevated environmental pollution.
Many harmful substances including toxic heavy elements are released,
due to anthropogenic activities such as agriculture and industry,
into the air, water and soil. Afterwards they can be easily taken
up by biosphere thus contaminating food consumed by humans. Once
accumulated in the body they may cause serious deleterious effects
on human health. Therefore, studies for identifying critical pollutants
in contaminated and the role of toxic elements in human populations
areas are needed.
In seeking solutions to these problems, increasing farm productivity,
supplementation targeted to high-risk groups combined or not with
program of food fortification and dietary diversification strategies
are the main intervention used to tackle micronutrient malnutrition
in developing countries. However, early impact evaluations of these
interventions indicate a low rate of progress in micronutrient malnutrition
control among African nations [5].
Many types of constraints have interfered with the success of nutrition
and /or environmental interventions in Africa; the most important
are political, socio-economic and technical.
The objective of this review is to highlight from IAEA’s perspective
“the role of nuclear and isotopic techniques in evaluating
and monitoring nutrition and environmental interventions in Africa
and to address some technical issues.
NUCLEAR
AND ISOTOPIC TECHNIQUES IN HUMAN NUTRITION AND RELATED ENVIRONMENTAL
STUDIES
Applications of isotope techniques in nutritional sciences are progressing
very rapidly in key areas of nutrition and health: assessment of
nutritional status, nutrient requirements, and micronutrient malnutrition;
detection of infections; analysis of foods; and air pollution measurements.
The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA's) main objective is
to promote the safe, secure and peaceful development of nuclear
technologies. The use of isotopes or nuclear related techniques
to evaluate human nutritional status and the nutritional quality
of the foods is within the IAEA’s program in the human health
area [6]. The IAEA’s activities in nutritional evaluation
include use of isotope technique for assessment of human body composition,
nutrient intake, and vitamin and mineral availability in developing
countries [7].
Mainly the focus of isotopic techniques is on measurements of breast-milk
intake, energy expenditure, micro/macronutrient status/bioavailability
and body composition. The stable isotope techniques, although still
costly, can be used effectively by food industry for developing
nutrient-fortified food products, by governmental and international
institutions for designing food fortification programs and public
health authorities for establishing reliable dietary recommendations
for intake of inorganic nutrients [8].
There are two forms of isotopic tracers: radioactive and stable.
Radioactive isotopes can be detected via their radiation. They have
many important applications, such as measurements of body composition,
uptake and bioavailability of micronutrients and urea breath test
to examine bacterial colonization by Helicobacter pylori. However,
the risk of radiation related health effects has overtime dampened
the use of radiotracers in human subjects. Stable isotopes on the
other hand are invaluable since there is virtually no health risk
involved in their use. They are, therefore, preferred for work in
humans, especially in infants and pregnant women. Many naturally
occurring elements exist as a mixture of two or more stable non-radioactive
isotopic forms. There are heavy stable isotopes (eg 54Fe, 56Fe,
57Fe, 58Fe, 64Zn, 66Zn, 68Zn, 70Zn) and light stable isotopes (eg
1H, 2H, 13C, 12C, 15N, 14N, 16O, 17O, 18O) [9].The main advantages
and disadvantages of these two forms of isotopic tracers are summarized
in the Table 1 from references [10,11,12,13].
The
stable isotopes can be administered either orally (water, food,
etc) or intravenously. Depending on the rate of absorption of the
administered compound, the stable isotopes will be incorporated
into metabolic products, such as body water, urea or CO2. These
can be sampled in saliva, milk, breath, urine, and stool. The ratio
of minor to major isotopes can then be determined by isotope ratio
mass spectroscopy, infrared absorption or emission spectroscopy
[9]. Nuclear techniques used in all stages of human life are summarized
in Table 2.
CONTRIBUTION FROM IAEA TO NUTRITION AND RELATED ENVIRONMENTAL
STUDIES
The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) is contributing to
alleviation malnutrition through strengthening the application of
isotopic and nuclear related techniques in human nutrition [7,9,14]
by offering technical solutions to improve monitoring techniques
and identifying effective strategies in nutrition intervention programs.
There are several programs within the IAEA, like Coordinated Research
Projects (CRP), Thematic Co-ordinated Research Projects (TCRP),
and Technical Cooperation Projects (TCP).
A Coordinated Research Project (CRP) is a mechanism to which group
of countries are brought together to work on a well-defined research
topic, and the mean duration of a CRP is 3 years. A modest annual
funding to developing countries is made available by the IAEA mainly
for sample collection, analysis, and supplies. Collaboration between
scientists from developing and industrialized countries is stimulated
and exchanges of information are encouraged through participation
in research coordination meetings (RCMs).
Recently,
a new type of CRP has been introduced that is dedicated for supporting
PhD students. Thematic Co-ordinated Research Projects or Capacity
Building CRP (T-CRP) is a new program increasing the scope of a
normal CRP for capacity building in developing countries. Pairs
of countries (developed and developing countries) are stimulated
to work together. T-CRP is promoting a postgraduate training in
the country of origin with a possibility of training in developed
country. It will have a longer duration up to 4-5 years.
TCPs (Technical cooperation projects) are substantially large national
projects contributing to socioeconomic development of a given Member
State. They are programmed for 2-4 years, and if on a regional basis,
they are called regional projects with multiple participating countries.
The TC Projects in Nutrition should have a strong Government support
of National Nutrition Programs. The main objective is transfer of
mature nuclear and related techniques for a specific problem at
the same time building up scientific and technical capacity in the
country. The implementation strategy for TC projects has to consider
several criteria for approval. There has to be a nutrition intervention
or health-related problem in need of evaluation. There must be direct
links between TC counterparts and the public health stakeholders
that can absorb the recommendations resulting from the project and
use them to modify interventions if needed. One of the advantages
of nuclear techniques over conventional methodology of evaluation
is the response time in the impact evaluation and the number of
subjects required. With this, the use of nuclear techniques can
increase the efficiency of the evaluation of such programs. In nutrition
interventions a multidisciplinary approach is required; a partnership
with public and/or private sectors is important for a successful
evaluation of the program. IAEA supports infrastructure (equipment
and supplies), workshops, subcontracts, experts, fellowships and
scientific visits.
Some
examples of human nutrition and related environmental studies within
the IAEA Nutrition Program [9] based on stable isotopes methodology
are:
1.
Estimation of total energy expenditure to determine the
caloric expenditure of people in their normal environment. It is
accurate and can be applied under field conditions. After administration
of a simple dose of doubly labeled water, 2H218O,
both isotopes equilibrate with total body water and are eliminated
differentially in body fluids over a period of days. Deuterium (2H)
leaves the body as water and 18O leaves it as water and
CO2. Thus, the difference the rate of loss of the two
isotopes (18O and 2H) is used to calculate CO2 production
of the subject, which in turn is used to calculate energy expenditure.
This isotopic technology is very accurate and thus the FAO/WHO/UNU
expert committee convened during 2001 to establish new energy recommendations
is using the results of investigations on energy expenditure of
young children in Cuba. Prior to this project no data existed from
Latin America to provide a scientific basis to formulate food programs
suited to the local conditions. Moreover, the data from the Cuba
study indicates that the existing values overestimate energy needs
in children below 7 years old [15]. This could be a good opportunity
for African countries to follow the Latin America experience and
start setting up their own energy recommendations.
2.
Lean Body Mass (Body Composition)
A trace dose of water labeled with 2H or 18O is administered and
allowed to equilibrate for 4-6 hours. Isotope enrichment in urine
or saliva samples is measured to calculate body water volume. Total
body water is used to quantify fat-free mass. Body composition is
calculated from measured body water and the hydration coefficient
of fat-free mass. The amount of fat (adipose) tissue is calculated
as the difference between total body weight and fat-free mass (lean
body mass). An increasing problem with obesity exists in countries
considered to be in “nutrition transition”. As a result
from the project in Chile, it was recognised that it is necessary
to reduce of the energy intake of children in order to prevent obesity
[16]. On the other hand, lean body mass can be considered a valuable
indicator to monitor body wasting in HIV/AIDS patient, which shows
a decrease in lean body mass and an increase in energy expenditure
and protein catabolism when compared to HIV negative subjects. In
the recently launched IAEA Regional Africa Project involving 9 countries,
isotopes will be used to assess the efficiency of food-based approaches
to improve nutritional status of people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA).
The pilot study will start in Uganda and Senegal.
3.
Breast Milk Intake
The mother is given a dose of 2H- or 18O-labeled water, which mixes
with the body water pool and is transferred to the baby via the
breast milk. By collecting samples of the mother’s saliva
or milk and the baby’s saliva or urine, the breast milk intake
of the baby can be calculated. For example, the IAEA gave technical
support to a community nutrition program in Senegal. The results
indicated that breast milk output was not influenced by supplementation.
In contrast, the lactose, total protein and zinc contents of milk
increased significantly in supplemented mothers [17]. The Agency’s
counterpart in Ghana has used the same technique to assess the impact
of food supplement on nutritional status of lactating mothers and
their infants. Results have shown that babies’ growth from
supplemented mothers was significantly higher than those from non-supplemented
mothers. The Ghana government will use the results to strengthen
its ongoing food supplementation program.
4.Trace
Element Bioavailability
The uptake and metabolism of labeled micronutrients can be traced
in-vivo. In fact, stable isotopes techniques provide the
most reliable way of measuring the uptake and bioavailability of
trace elements in humans. As a result of the IAEA’s activities
in Chile the government modified its policy for pre-school children
nutrition intervention programs (coverage of ~1.3 million). The
study had shown that anaemia was reduced from 28.8% to less than
8.8% within a year after using foods fortified in iron and zinc
in a sample of 300 children [9]. This techniques can be used to
determine the effectiveness of fortification and supplementation
programs in several developing countries and could be useful to
assess the success of new programs in Africa (see table 3).
5.Analysis
of Foods
Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) is very effective technique due
to its exceptional sensitivity for several trace elements. Inductively
Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) also offers multi-element
determinations. The application of NAA-related methods is particularly
attractive for developing countries since many research reactors
are available to provide the needed neutron source. In Libya, for
example, under an IAEA project this nuclear method is used to determine
food nutritional values and dietary intake of minor and trace elements
[9].
6.Osteoporosis
Low energy x-rays are passed through the bones to measure the mineral
(calcium) content of the bones using DEXA (Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry).
The precision of DEXA is very high and the data can be standardised
for age, weight, height and ethnic status.
A recent CRP has examined global variations in bone mineral density
of young adults in nine countries. A total of 6207 subjects were
recruited. Approximately 12-20% of the global variation in bone
mineral density is due to anthropometric differences and the country
of origin accounts for 4-10%. Significant differences were found
in bone mass that, if persisting into old age, may contribute to
2-3 fold difference in fracture risk [18].
7. Detection of Infection
The
13C-urea breath test is used to detect Helicobacter
pylori infection in humans. Breath is collected for a base
value before a 13C-labeled urea is administered. The
enzyme urease of H. pylori breaks down the urea into ammonium
and labeled bicarbonate. The latter compound will be metabolised
by the person into carbon dioxide and expired. After 20-30 minutes
a second breath sample is collected and measured for the label.
A CRP on H. pylori infection in children revealed infection
rates of 86% in Senegal and 87% in Benin. In Indonesia, 58-67% of
malnourished children tested positive for H. pylori, while
33% of the well-nourished children were infected [9].
IAEA-SUPPORTED
NUTRITION AND RELATED ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES IN AFRICA
Resources
spent by IAEA :
African investigators have not been very active as participants
of the IAEA projects in Nutrition and Health-Related Environmental
Studies. The total amount of contributions to the African continent
(Not all 54 countries, including 48 in Sub-Saharan Africa and 6
in North Africa are members of IAEA) by the Nutritional and Health-Related
Environmental Studies Section at IAEA in the last 15-20 years is
in the order of US$ 400,000.00 for CRPs and US$ 2,000,000.00 for
TCs projects. Please refer to Tables 4, 5 and 6.
Some
examples of African participation in running CRPs:
A CRP on “application of nuclear techniques in the prevention
of degenerative diseases (obesity, non-insulin dependent diabetes
and coronary heart diseases) in ageing” has only one country
from Africa: Nigeria. A one year follow-up of lean cohort (BMI 21-22
kg>m2) in Nigeria has shown: (i) increase in body weight and
BMI (ii) increased body fat (iii) increased prevalence of obesity
and (iv) increased level of fasting insulin and insulin-glucose
ratio. The conclusions are that the population is yet to reach the
BMI threshold above which worsening of glycaemia status accompanies
the increases in weight gain. [19,20]
Benin and Senegal are participants in the CRP on “the use
of isotopes techniques to examine the significance of Helicobacter
pylori infection and malnutrition”. The prevalence of
this infection in children was measured successfully by the 13C
urea breath test. Measuring anthropometric growth and decrease of
infection will be assessed by further investigations using antibiotics
and probiotics donated from Belgium.
Kenya and Morocco are participants in a recently launched CRP on
“application of isotopic and nuclear techniques in the study
of nutrition-pollution interactions and their impact on the nutritional
status of human subjects in developing country populations”.
The objective of the research study in Kenya will be to assess the
effect of pollutants eg lead and cadmium on nutritional status of
pregnant women and new-born babies in polluted areas, and the objective
of the research study of Morocco will be to evaluate the degree
of pollution of ground water in industrial areas and its effect
on nutritional status in school children [21]
Ghana is participating in a new T-CRP on “isotopic and complementary
tools for the study of micronutrient status and interaction in developing
country populations exposed to multiple nutritional deficiencies”
in collaboration with WHO to investigate “Evaluation of vitamin
A pool in post partum women supplemented with vitamin A, using carbon
isotopes”.
Kenya and South Africa participated in the CRP on workplace air
pollution monitoring aimed at linking results of chemical analyses
with pulmonary and other diseases found in exposed workers. The
participants were analysing airborne particulate matter at workplaces
and biological materials such as hair, nails, urine and blood, to
assess biological exposure.
Ghana has been participating in the CRP on “Validation of
plants as biomonitors of trace element atmospheric pollution”.
In the study, the levels of toxic element pollution as obtained
by analyses of local lichen species are being assessed in gold-mining
and other industrial areas situated in the moist evergreen and semi-deciduous
forests in Ghana.
Within the framework of a CRP on “Health impacts of mercury
cycling in contaminated environments”, the Tanzanian participant
is investigating exposure levels to mercury in the Lake Victoria
gold fields. The recovery of gold in the area involves the use of
mercury amalgamation because it is easy, cheap, and does not require
sophisticated tools. The gold-mercury amalgam is placed in a firing
pot or retort and fired to evaporate mercury and leave behind gold.
In this way, highly toxic mercury enters the environment and potentially
contaminates food.
Recently a new CRP on the “Use of nuclear and related analytical
techniques in studying human exposure to toxic elements consumed
through foodstuffs contaminated by industrial activities”
has been started. It aims at determining the extent to which toxic
element levels in food are affected by surrounding industrial activities
and to assess potential human exposure from the consumption of such
foodstuffs. Two African countries participate in this collaborative
research: Ghana and Nigeria
Selected Technical Cooperation Projects-TCPs in Africa:
The most successful TCP in Africa is on “Isotope aided evaluation
of community program” in Senegal. The TCP in Senegal provided
the local authorities with irrefutable scientific evidence that
is needed to assess its community nutrition program. The isotopic
methods are being used to measure how much breast milk the baby
is taking, the nutrients that are being transferred and the body
composition of both mother and baby. It can indicate the best time
during pregnancy at which to provide supplement to the baby that
is being weaned, and the value of weaning foods to be added to their
diets.
The project in Senegal was aimed to evaluate the food supplementary
program (Community Nutrition Program (CNP) launched by the Senegalese
Government in order to protect the most vulnerable groups (women
and children) in poor urban areas of Senegal. The study has shown,
using isotopic and related techniques, that the supplemented food
has significantly influenced the quality of the breast-milk (increased
concentrations of lactose, protein and Zn). As a consequence, growth
of the babies at 3 months was significantly above normal. The results
also suggest probable improved levels of fat-soluble vitamins, particularly
vitamin A.
These results have been presented to the National Commission for
Combating Malnutrition of the Senegalese Government and have been
used to refine the forthcoming Senegalese Nutrition Program (PRS).
The PRS is a major national nutrition initiative planned for a period
of 10 years (2002-2012), resulted from the impact of the CNP.
The TCP on “Breast milk trace-element composition and infant
growth” in Ghana is completed. The objective was to evaluate
a nationwide food supplementation program (SFP) targeting lactating
women and their infants using isotope and related techniques. The
project was implemented in collaboration with the Nutrition Unit,
Ministry of Health, headed by the National Coordinator of the National
Supplementary Feeding & Education Program (NSFEP). The results
from this project is being used for an overall review of the national
nutrition intervention.
The TCP on “Food analysis and routine monitoring of aerosols
and drinking water sources” in Libya is aimed at establishing
a national capability for the determination of food nutritional
values and dietary intake of minor and trace elements, and for routine
monitoring of aerosols and drinking water sources.
The objective of the TCP project on “The effect of air and
water pollution on public health” is to increase the country’s
capability for monitoring and control of air and water pollution
levels with the aim to prevent cancer and respiratory diseases in
Madagascar.
In Nigeria the TCP project on “Trace element methods for studies:
Workplace monitoring” is being implemented. The counterparts
are strengthening the national capability for monitoring occupational
exposure of workers to selected air pollutants and assessing the
health hazards associated with various levels of exposure.
Some projects ended before its implementation due to external factors
like the TC “Evaluation of supplementary infant feeding practices
in Ethiopia” which had failed because of lack of government
support to start the program and the TC “Use of isotopes in
investigating micronutrient deficiencies” in Sierra Leone
which had failed because of the country’s war.
FUTURE
INITIATIVES
Africa
is facing several challenges to overcome the need for eliminating
malnutrition, especially in women and children. One-way of doing
it is by introduction of multiple or single supplementation/fortification
programs of a potential nutrient or diet interactions in the target
population. Several African countries do have such programs but
the challenge is their evaluation, sustainability and effectiveness.
Nuclear and isotopic techniques are valuable tools in helping to
meet the nutritional challenges. It seems there is a lack of awareness
of the IAEA activity in Nutrition by the African governments. Hence
it is recommended that the IAEA avenue be utilised effectively.
There
are several future opportunities for the African countries to strengthen
capacity building and participating in future IAEA CRPs. Some examples
foreseen CRPs (2003-2004): 1. CRP on nutritional and other factors
contributing to IUGR (intra-uterine growth restriction); 2. CRP
on increasing obesity in developing countries and its implication
on public health; 3. CRP on Calcium metabolism in osteoporosis in
the elderly; 4. Regional project on HIV/AIDS and nutrition using
body composition measurements; and 5. CRP on assessing exposure
to toxic elements using the placenta as a biomarker.
Similarly,
for the next TC cycle 2005-2006, the time is ripe for the African
Countries to submit new projects through their Atomic Energy Authorities
to be submitted to the Agency by the end of this year 2003.
Table
1
Advantages and disadvantages radioactive and stable isotopes |
Isotopes/Utility |
Radioisotopes |
Enriched
Stable Isotopes |
Advantages |
- authentic
tracers
- easily
detectable
- generally
inexpensive
- sample
preparation minimal
- whole
body measurement, retention can be determined
|
- minimal
health risk, can be used in infants, pregnant and lactating
women
- multi-elements
procedure
- tracers
may be followed for longer periods
- samples
can be stored without loss of tracers
- reanalysis
possibl
|
Disadvantages |
- safety
concerns, some risk through exposure to radiation
- unsuitable
for infants and children, pregnant and lactating women
- decay
time
- only
one radioactive element can be studied
- sample
analysis must be timed based on half-life
- expensive
waste problem
|
- not
true tracers, larger amount needed
- expensive
- extensive
sample preparation
- still
complex and costly analysis
- direct
determination of retention not possible
|
Table
2
Nuclear and Isotopic Techniques in Nutritional Sciences |
Life
Stage |
Nutritional
Disorders |
Applicable
Nuclear Techniques |
Embryo/Foetus |
Intrauterine
Growth Retardation; Low birth weight; Protein-Energy Malnutrition,
Folate, Iodine, Vitamin A, Iron Deficiency |
- RIA
(ferritin, follate, T3, T4, TSH and
other hormones
- Doubly
labled water 2H218O (energy
expenditure)
- Deuterium
lableled water 2H2O (breast milk intake,
body composition)
- State
isotopes (micronutrients, eg 57Fe, 67Zn)
- 13C
and 15N labeled substrates (macronutrients, Helicobacter
pylori)
- DEXA,
CT (bone density, body composition)
|
Neonate |
Infant
& Young Child |
Adolescent |
Protein-Energy
Malnutrition; Iodine, Iron, Folate, Calcium, Deficiency; Obesity;
Cancer; HIV/AIDS; Osteporosis |
Pregnant
& Lactating Mothers |
Adults |
Elderly |
Notes:
DEXA=Dual Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry; CT=Computer Tomography,
RIA=Radioimmunoassay; TSH=Thyroid Stimulating Hormone; T4=Thyroxin |
Table
3
Food fortification status in Africa, January 2001 (source:
reference 21) |
Country |
Status |
Legislation |
Botswana |
Sorghum
meal fortified with vitamins and minerals |
Voluntary |
Ghana |
cooking
oil fortified with A |
Voluntary
(pending) |
Kenya |
Cooking
fats and margarin fortified with A and D |
Voluntary
Claim: enriched with vitamins |
Malawi |
Margarine
fortified with A and D |
Voluntary |
Morocco |
Cooking
oil fortified with A and D |
Voluntary
(with logo) |
Morocco |
Flour
fortified with B-complex and iron |
Mandatory
(pending) |
Namibia |
Maize
meal fortified with A, B1, B2, B6,
folate, niacin, iron |
Voluntary
Claim: vitamin-A enriched or vitamin enriched |
Nigeria |
'Enriched'
wheat flour (B1, B2, niacin, iron) |
Mandatory |
Nigeria |
Margarine
fortified with A, D, B1, B2 |
Voluntary |
South
Africa |
'Enriched'
maize meal (B2, niacin) |
Mandatory |
South
Africa |
Maize
meal fortified A, B1, B2, B6,
folate, niacin, iron, calcium |
Voluntary |
South
Africa |
Bread
fortified with A, B1, B2, B6,
folate, niacin, iron, calcium |
Voluntary |
South
Africa |
Margarine
fortified with A and D |
Voluntary |
Zamiba |
Sugar
fortified with vitamin A |
Mandatory |
Zambia |
Maize
flour |
Mandatory
(pending) |
Zimbabwe |
Maize
meal, wheat flour, margarine, bread fortified with A, B-complex,
iron |
Voluntary:
endorsed by Ministry of Health |
Zimbabwe |
Hammermill
fortification of milled maize with vitamin mix (A, B1,
B2, B6, B12, folic acid,
niacin, iron, zinc) |
Voluntary |
Table
4
Running CRPs in NUTRITION in AFRICA |
Co-ordinated
Research Projects |
Country |
Status |
Application
of Nuclear Techniques in the Prevention of Degenerative Diseases
(Obesity, Non-insulin Dependent Diabetes and Coronary Heart
Disease) in Ageing |
Brazil,
Chile, Chine, Cuba, India, Jamaica, Mexico, NIGERIA |
Completing |
Use
of Isotopic Techniques to Examine the Significance of Infection
and Other Insults in Early Childhood to Diarrhoeal Morbidity
and mal-assimilation and Failure to Thrive |
Argentina,
Bangladesh, Belgium, BENIN,
Chile, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Pakistan, SENEGAL |
Completing |
Application
of Isotopic and Nuclear Techniques in the Study of Nutrition-Pollution
Interactions and their Impact on the Nutrtional Staus of Human
Subjects in Developing Country Populations |
Bangladesh,
Brazil, Chile, China, India, KENYA,
Korea, MOROCCO,
Peru, Sweden, Vietnam |
Implemented
2001 |
Isotopic
and Complementary Tools for the Study of Micronutrient Status
and Interaction in Developing Country Populations Exposed
to Multiple Nutritional Deficiencies |
Bangladesh,
GHANA,
India, Indonesia, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Thailand |
Implemented
2001 |
Table
5
Running and completed TC/National projects in NUTRITION in
AFRICA |
Technical
Co-operation Projects |
Country |
Status |
Evaluation
of Sumpplementary Infant Feeding Practices |
Ethiopia |
Completed
2002 |
Breast
Milk Trace-Element Composition and Infant Growth |
Ghana |
Completed
2002 |
Isotope
Aided Evaluation of Community Program |
Senegal |
Completed
2002 |
Zinc-vitamin
A supplementation in the treatment of malaria attacks in children
under six year of age in Burkina Faso |
Burkina
Faso |
Implemented 2003 |
Support
and evaluation of the food nutrition program in Madagascar |
Madagascar |
Implemented
2003 |
Monitoring
of the national mandatory food fortification program aimed
at addressing micro-nutrient deficiencies using isotope techniques |
South
Africa |
Implemented
2003 |
Using
stable isotopic techniques to study the impact of multi-micronutrient
supplementation on pregnancy outcomes |
Egypt |
Implemented
2003 |
Food
supplementation strategy for women in Senegalese rural areas |
Senegal |
Implemented
2003 |
Evaluation
of complementary feeding program in Ghana |
Ghana |
Implemented
2003 |
Table
6
Running TC/Regional projects in NUTRITION |
TC-regional
Projects |
Countries |
Status |
Early
Diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori Infection Through the Use
of Nuclear Techniques (ARCALLIV) |
Argentin,
Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Costa Rica, Cuba, Ecuador, El Salvador,
Guatemala, Mexico, Panama, Peru, Venezuela |
Implemented
2001 |
Elimination
of micronutrient malnutrition in the East Asia and the Pacific |
Regional
East Asia and Pacific |
Implemented
2003 |
Assessing
nutrition intervention programs related to HIV/AIDS in Africa,
using isotopes and nuclear techniques |
Burkina
Faso, Cameroon, Ghana, Kenya, Senegal, South Africa, Uganda,
Tanzania |
Implemented
2003 |
REFERENCE
1. SCN. United Nations System Standing Committee
on Nutrition. Fourth Report on the World
Nutrition Situation. 2000.
2. Sifri Z, Darnton-Hill I, Baker SK, Agbendech
M and AM Aguayao A Concise Overview
of Micronutrient Deficiency in Africa
and Future Directions. African Journal of Food and Nutritional
Sciences 2002; 2 (2): 1-10.
3. WHO. World
Health Organization. The World Health Report,
2002.
4. UN. United Nations General
Assembly. Resolution of the United Nations General
Assembly 55th Session; A/Res/55/2 United Nations Millennium
Declaration. 18 September 2002.
5. ACC/SCN. United Nations System-Standing Committee on Nutrition;
Commission on The Nutrition Challenges
of 21st Century-Ending Malnutrition by 2020; An Agenda
for Change in the Millennium. 1997.
6. Iyengar V Nuclear and Isotopic Techniques for
Addressing Nutritional Problems, with Special Reference to Current
Applications in Developing Countries. Food
and Nutrition Bulletin. 2002; 23 (1): 3-10.
7. Valencia
ME and V Iyengar Isotopic Tools for Strengthening Health and Nutritional Monitoring and their
Current Application in Developing Regions of the World. Food
and Nutrition Bulletin 2002; 23 (3) 150-157.
8. Walczyk T The Potential
of Inorganic Mass Spectrometry in Mineral and Trace Element Nutrition
Research. Fresenius J. Anal. Chem.
2002; 370:444-453.
9. IAEA-NAHRES Brochure “Nuclear and Isotopes Techniques in
Nutrition and Health Related Environmental Studies Throughout
the Human Life Cycle” IAEA, Vienna,
2002.
10. Patterson
KY and C Veillon Stable Isotopes of Minerals as Metabolic
Tracers in Human Nutrition Research. Exp.
Biol. Med. 2001; 226(4):
271-282.
11. Walczyk T Stable
Isotope Labels as a Tool to Study Mineral and Trace Element Absorption
in Humans- An Introduction Focusing Iron and Zinc. “IAEA- Regional Training Course
for East Asia Pacific on Application of Isotopic Techniques
in Human Nutrition Research” Bangkok, Thailand, 1999.
12. Mellon
FA and B Sandstrom Stable Isotopes in Human Nutrition.
Inorganic Nutrient Metabolism. Academic
Press Limited .San Diego, CA, USA.
1996.
13. Abrams
SA
Using Stable Isotopes to Assess Mineral Absorption and Utilization
by Children. Am. J.
Clin. Nutr. 1999; 70:
955-64.
14. Iyengar V Uncovering the
Hidden Links, Nuclear and Isotopes Techniques Target Nutritional
Needs. IAEA Bulletin 2001: 43(3).
15. Hernandez-Triana M., Salazar G. Diaz
E, Sanchez V, Basabe B, Gonzalez and MH
Diaz Total Energy Expenditure by Double-Labeled
Water Method in Rural Preschool Children in Cuba. Food and Nutrition Bulletin. 2002;
23(3): 76-81.
16. Milagros MV, Salazar G, Vio F, Hernandez
J and J Rojas Nutritional Status and Body Composition in Chilean
Preschool Children Attending Day Care Centers.
Food and Nutrition Bulletin. 2002;
23 (3): 250-253.
17. Cissé AS, Dossou
N, Ndiaye M, Guèye AL, Diop EHI, Diaham Bl, Guiro AT, Cissé D, Sarr
CSB and S Wade Stable Isotope Aided Evaluation of Community
Nutrition Program: Effect of Food Supplementation Schemes on Maternal
and Infant Nutritional Status. Food and Nutrition Bulletin. 2002; 23 (3): 169-173.
18. Parr RM, Mccloskey EV, Aras N, Balogh A, Borelli A, Krishnan, Lobo
G, Qin LL, Zhang Y, Cvijetic
S, Zaichick V, Lim-Abraham M, Bose K,
Wynchank S and GV Iyengar Contribution
of Calcium and other Dietary Components to Global Variations in
Bone Mineral Density in Young Adults. Food
and Nutrition Bulletin. 2002; 23 (3): 180-184.
19. IAEA/NAHRES Report-70. Report on the Second Research Co-Ordination
Meeting on “Application of Nuclear Techniques in the Prevention
of Degenerative Diseases (Obesity and Non-Insulin Dependent Diseases)
in Ageing”. IAEA, Vienna, 2002.
20. Shetty P, Iynegar
V, Sawaya A, Diaz E, Ma G, Hernandez-Triana
M, Forrester, Yajnik C, Forrester T, Valencia
M, Rush E, Adeyemo A, Jahoor
F and S Roberts Application of Stable Isotopic Techniques in
the Prevention of Degenerative Diseases Like Obesity and NIDDM in
Developing Societies. Food and Nutrition Bulletin. 2002; 23 (3): 174-179.
21. IAEA/NAHRES Report-71. Report on the First Research Co-Ordination Meeting on “Application
of Isotopic Nuclear Techniques in the Study of Nutrition-Pollution
Interactions and their Impact on the Nutritional Status of Human
Subjects in Developing Country Populations”. IAEA, Vienna, 2002.
22. Food Fortification Gains
Support in Africa. Nutriview 20011:3.
|